Buffy's Bulletin
🐥 Peeps Protein Iced Coffee with Dreamy Cloud Cold Foam
Your Easter coffee era just got a serious glow-up — and a serious protein boost.
A Peeps protein iced coffee is a high-protein Easter coffee drink made with a flavored protein coffee powder, Fairlife milk, sugar-free marshmallow syrup, and a fluffy marshmallow-flavored cold foam tinted yellow to look like a Peeps chick. It delivers the nostalgic marshmallow sweetness of Peeps candy in a creamy iced coffee format with over 30 grams of protein per serving.
Easter just called — and it wants you to put a Peeps chick on your iced coffee. 🐣
This Peeps protein iced coffee combines Buff Coffee Creamy Coffee with Fairlife milk, toasted marshmallow sugar-free syrup, and the fluffiest, dreamiest yellow cloud cold foam you've ever seen. It's sweet, creamy, and marshmallow-y in all the right ways — and because it's built on Buff Coffee, you're also sneaking in 32 grams of protein without trying.
It's the Easter treat that actually loves you back. 🐥
What's in a Peeps Protein Iced Coffee?
The magic here is layering: you've got a creamy protein coffee base spiked with toasted marshmallow syrup, topped with a thick yellow cloud foam that looks like it came straight off a Peeps chick. The garnish? One actual Peeps chick perched right on top. It's a vibe, it's a photo moment, and it's a genuinely delicious drink.
Here's what makes it work:
Buff Coffee Creamy Coffee — 18g protein, café-quality flavor, zero fat, mixes smooth with milk
Fairlife Whole Milk — ultra-filtered for extra protein and creaminess (hello, 13 more grams)
Toasted Marshmallow Sugar-Free Syrup — brings that signature Peeps sweetness without the sugar spike
Marshmallow Fluff Cold Foam — frothed with heavy cream and tinted yellow for the full chick effect ☁️🐥
How to Make a Peeps Protein Iced Coffee at Home
Ingredients
- 1 scoop Buff Coffee Creamy Coffee
- 8 fl oz Fairlife Whole Milk
- 2 tbsp toasted marshmallow sugar-free syrup (Jordan's Skinny or Torani work great)
- 1 cup ice
- 3 tbsp heavy cream
- 1 tbsp Fairlife milk (for cold foam)
- 1 tbsp marshmallow fluff
- ¼ tsp vanilla extract
- 2–3 drops yellow gel food coloring
- 1 tsp yellow sanding sugar (rim garnish)
- 1 yellow Peeps chick (garnish)
Instructions for the Easter Carrot Cake Iced Latte
Step 1 — Mix your protein coffee base. Combine Buff Coffee Creamy Coffee, Fairlife milk, and toasted marshmallow sugar-free syrup in a shaker or cup. Shake or stir until fully dissolved.
Step 2 — Build your glass. Lightly wet the rim of your glass and dip into yellow sanding sugar. Fill with ice and pour your coffee base over top.
Step 3 — Make the Dreamy Cloud Cold Foam. In a small jar or frother cup, combine heavy cream, Fairlife milk, marshmallow fluff, vanilla extract, and yellow food coloring. Froth with a handheld milk frother for 20–30 seconds until thick and fluffy.
Step 4 — Float the cloud. Slowly pour the yellow foam over the back of a spoon onto your iced coffee for a clean, dreamy layer. ☁️
Step 5 — Garnish & serve. Perch your Peeps chick right on top, sprinkle a little extra sanding sugar over the foam, and serve immediately. Stir before sipping!
Nutrition & Macros
Macros are estimates and will vary based on milk choice, Buff Coffee flavor, and serving size. Always check your product labels.
Per Serving
Calories ~ 435
Protein ~32g
Carbohydrates ~18g
Fat ~23g
To reduce fat: Swap heavy whipping cream in the foam for coconut cream or a lighter whipping alternative.
To reduce sugar: Cut the brown sugar in the syrup to ½ tbsp or use a sugar-free sweetener.
Tips for the Best Marshmallow Cold Foam
Getting cloud-like cold foam is all about technique:
- Use cold heavy cream. Warm cream won't froth properly — keep everything cold straight from the fridge.
- Microwave the marshmallow fluff for 5–10 seconds first. It loosens up and incorporates way more easily, preventing clumps in your foam.
- Froth for a full 20–30 seconds. Don't rush it — the longer you go, the thicker and fluffier your cloud gets.
- Gel food coloring > liquid. Liquid food coloring can thin out your foam. Wilton yellow gel coloring gives the most vibrant chick-yellow hue without messing with the texture.
Made this one? Tag us at @buffchicksupplements on Instagram — we want to see your Easter lattes! 🥕☕
Written by the Buff Chick team — a women-owned supplement brand focused on evidence-based fitness nutrition